What Happens Next?

Thank you for submitting your work to The Schola. All submissions are reviewed within a 2–3 week period. Manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening for compliance and scholarly suitability, with selected manuscripts proceeding to external blind review.

Decision Notification

Authors whose work is accepted will receive an email from the editorial office outlining the outcome and any next steps. For submissions that are not selected, individual notifications or status updates are not provided.

Understanding the Decision

If your manuscript is not selected for publication, this reflects the outcome of a competitive editorial process and does not constitute a judgment of your potential. Editorial decisions are final and are not subject to appeal. Here are a few important things to keep in mind:

• The Impersonal Nature of Selection: Rejection in academic publishing is often determined by factors such as a journal’s scope, the number of publication slots, or alignment with its thematic priorities. Such decisions rarely reflect on your intellect or scholarly abilities.
• Rejection as a Point of Learning: Every submission, regardless of the outcome, provides valuable experience. Take time to reflect on the process – from research and writing to submission – and consider how the experience may inform future work.
• The Importance of Persistence: Setbacks are a natural part of any meaningful learning or creative journey. Persistence, reflection, and a willingness to grow are essential to long-term development in any field. See this as a small hurdle on your broader educational journey, one that builds resilience.

Feedback and Communication Policy

Due to the volume of submissions, individualized feedback is not provided for manuscripts that are not selected for publication. Inquiries regarding general suitability may receive brief, non-specific guidance at the discretion of the editorial office. The journal does not offer individual consultations regarding editorial decisions or review procedures.

Supporting Your Academic Growth

Regardless of the outcome of this particular submission, we commend you for taking the initiative to engage in research and the publication process. Your willingness to share your work marks an important step in your scholarly growth. We strongly encourage you to explore the resources on our site as you continue developing your academic skills.

Revision and Resubmission

If a manuscript partially meets the selection criteria, we may invite the author to revise and resubmit. A revise-and-resubmit decision indicates that the work shows promise but requires substantive changes before it can be considered for publication. Revision invitations are issued at the discretion of the journal and do not guarantee acceptance.

Recognition of Outstanding Work

In the fall, we celebrate outstanding student work by recognizing notable essays published in the previous academic year. These essays, formerly known as Magna essays, are selected for their intellectual courage and ingenuity, showcasing original thought and critical thinking. Authors of these distinguished pieces are recognized each September. While the Magna distinction was previously awarded quarterly, it is now an annual honor bestowed upon the most exceptional essays.

Publication

The journal is published in the first week of each issue month: March, June, September, and December. Authors receive digital copies of their published essays to facilitate scholarly sharing and verify publication, though works are not assigned a DOI. The official author’s copy issued by the journal features distinct front and back covers to deter tampering.

For Further Information

Please visit the FAQ.