What Happens Next?

Thank you for submitting your work to The Schola. All submissions are reviewed within a 2–3 week period. Manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening for compliance and scholarly suitability. Selected manuscripts proceed to external blind review. All authors will be notified of the editorial decision by email.

Editorial Outcomes

The following outcomes are possible. All editorial decisions are final and not subject to appeal.

• Desk Rejection: Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's formal requirements or scholarly threshold.
• Rejection Following Review: Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's scholarly standards following editorial review.
• Revise and Resubmit: Issued rarely and at editorial discretion, this decision constitutes a rejection of the manuscript in its current form, accompanied by an expression of editorial interest in its development. Authors who wish to pursue revision may resubmit through the portal as a new submission, entering the manuscript, in a more developed form, into the full review process, where additional rounds of editorial consideration remain possible. A new submission fee applies, and acceptance is not guaranteed.
• Acceptance with Revisions: The manuscript is accepted for publication, subject to specified revisions and full compliance with the House Style Guide.

The Schola receives submissions from students engaged in rigorous scholarly work. Whatever the outcome, that effort carries value.

Understanding the Decision

If your manuscript is not selected for publication, it reflects the outcome of a competitive editorial process. Selection is influenced by a range of editorial considerations, including a manuscript's contribution, its fit with the journal's scope, and the limited number of papers that can be published in each issue.

Feedback and Communication Policy

Due to the volume of submissions, individualized feedback is not provided for manuscripts that are not selected for publication. The editorial office is unable to respond to inquiries regarding specific submissions, editorial decisions, or post-decision correspondence.

Recognition of Outstanding Work

In its first decade, The Schola highlighted especially notable essays published in the previous academic year. These essays, initially recognized under the Magna and Summa distinctions and later as Notable Essays, were selected for their intellectual courage and ingenuity, reflecting original thought and critical inquiry. Today, publication itself stands as the recognition.

Publication

Each issue of the journal is released in the first week of its publication month—March, June, September, and December—and is available as a single-issue edition. Authors receive digital copies of their published essays to facilitate scholarly sharing and verify publication, though works are not assigned a DOI. The official author’s copy issued by the journal features distinct front and back covers to deter tampering.

For Further Information

Please visit the FAQ.